Volume 59

Table of contents volume 59
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision Title
BVerfGE 59, 1-36Order of 3 November 19811 BvR 632/80,
1 BvR 909/80,
1 BvR 936/80 inter alia
Changes to the selection process for prospective medical students; transitional rules (‘wait time oriented lottery’) for long-term waitlisted candidates; inadmissibility of constitutional complaints directly challenging provisions relating to the awarding of places at university
BVerfGE 59, 36-52Order of 10 November 19811 BvL 18/77,
1 BvL 19/77
Constitutionality of the Federal Social Court’s case-law on the reasonableness of other occupations in assessing inability to work; classification of occupations by varying levels of ability
BVerfGE 59, 52-63Order of 10 November 19811 BvR 894/78No financial assistance available under the Youth Welfare Act for grandparents raising their grandchildren
BVerfGE 59, 63-95Order of 10 November 19812 BvR 1058/79Design of legal protections for employees of Eurocontrol; jurisdiction of the Administrative Tribunal of the International Labour Organization
BVerfGE 59, 95-98Order of 10 November 19812 BvR 1118/80Searches of private homes by law enforcement in accordance with the general principle of proportionality; constitutional complaint against execution of a search warrant
BVerfGE 59, 98-104Order of 10 November 19812 BvR 1060/81Objectively arbitrary denial of an appeal on points of law challenging conviction and sentencing made without a request by the public prosecution office as to the appeal of the sentence (§ 349 Code of Criminal Procedure)
BVerfGE 59, 104-119Order of 24 November 19812 BvL 4/80Definition of ‘executive staff’ in the Works Constitution Act
BVerfGE 59, 119-128Order of 24 November 19812 BvC 1/81Constitutionality of voting by post
BVerfGE 59, 128-172Order of 16 December 19811 BvR 898/79,
1 BvR 1132/79,
1 BvR 1150/79 inter alia
Requirement of a ‘commitment to German identity’ in the Federal Expellees Act; protection of legitimate expectations in regard to the confiscation of displaced persons’ identification cards
BVerfGE 59, 172-215Order of 21 October 19811 BvR 802/78,
1 BvR 839/78,
1 BvR 841/78 inter alia
Denial of an available place for pre-clinical medical studies due to uncertainty as to the availability of a place for the completion of the qualifying medical degree
BVerfGE 59, 216-231Order of 12 January 19822 BvR 113/81Renewed change to municipality name previously determined by law as part of a comprehensive local government reform
BVerfGE 59, 231-274Order of 13 January 19821 BvR 848/77,
1 BvR 1047/77,
1 BvR 916/78 inter alia
Consideration of the freedom of broadcasters in determining whether the relationships between radio stations and certain ‘freelancers’ involved in programming are to be classified as permanent employment relationships
BVerfGE 59, 275-279Order of 26 January 19821 BvR 1295/80,
1 BvR 201/81,
1 BvR 881/81 inter alia
Violation of the requirement of wearing a helmet while riding a motorcycle as an administrative offence
BVerfGE 59, 280-287Order of 26 January 19822 BvR 856/81Preliminary injunction; suspension of an order of a Higher Regional Court on the admissibility of an extradition of an Austrian citizen to Italy based on a conviction and a life sentence issued by a Florentine court in absentia for a bomb attack
BVerfGE 59, 287-302Order of 27 January 19821 BvR 562/78In exceptional cases, voluntary contributions to the statutory pension insurance scheme made at the time of the onset of disability can have the effect of reducing the pension amount
BVerfGE 59, 302-329Order of 27 January 19821 BvR 807/80Commercial payroll accounting conducted by persons who have passed the commercial assistant examination; advertising for the activities of making business accounts and conducting ongoing payroll accounting
BVerfGE 59, 330-335Order of 9 February 19821 BvR 799/78Violation of the right to be heard; use of preclusive provisions in enforcement proceedings pursuant to § 890 of the Code of Civil Procedure
BVerfGE 59, 336-359Judgment of 9 February 19821 BvR 698/79,
1 BvR 771/79
Right to choose whether to open hair salon on Saturday afternoons and Monday mornings
BVerfGE 59, 360-392Judgment of 9 February 19821 BvR 845/79Right of parents to information on school practices that adversely affect their right to educate their children; confidentiality obligation of school counsellor in exceptional situations (School Administrative Act of Bremen)

Volume 58

Table of contents volume 58
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 58, 1-45Order of 23 June 19812 BvR 1107/77,
2 BvR 1124/77,
2 BvR 195/79
International jurisdiction of Belgian courts over fee claims by Eurocontrol
BVerfGE 58, 45-67Order of 23 June 19812 BvL 14/79Land law revocation of statutory duties of a water and land district covering municipalities from a single association and transfer of those duties to the association itself (Schleswig-Holstein)
BVerfGE 58, 68-81Order of 23 June 19812 BvR 1067/80No constitutional guarantee of present system of healthcare coverage for civil servants and beneficiaries
BVerfGE 58, 81-136Order of 1 July 19811 BvR 874/77,
1 BvR 322/78,
1 BvR 324/78 inter alia
Limits to the credit allocated to technical school or university studies in the public pension scheme for persons who voluntarily joined the scheme as a compulsorily insured after 1972 or made use of the ability to make subsequent contributions on that basis
BVerfGE 58, 81-136Order of 1 July 19811 BvR 874/77,
1 BvR 322/78,
1 BvR 324/78 inter alia
Dissenting opinion of President Benda and Justice Katzenstein
BVerfGE 58, 137-152Order of 14 July 19811 BvL 24/78Obligation to provide a reference copy of a costly, limited edition publication to state libraries without compensation
BVerfGE 58, 153-159Order of 14 July 19811 BvL 28/80Inadmissibility of a referral (from a court) pursuant to Art. 100(1) of the Basic Law (relevance of the question to the underlying proceedings; Maternity Protection Act)
BVerfGE 58, 159-163Order of 14 July 19811 BvR 575/80Requirement of a finding of fault when imposing sanctions pursuant to § 890(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure
BVerfGE 58, 163-168Order of 6 October 19812 BvR 1290/80Factually untenable and objectively arbitrary decision of a lower court as a violation of Art. 3(1) of the Basic Law
BVerfGE 58, 169-170Order of 6 October 19812 BvC 3/81Electoral complaint (brought by political parties; prior objection made in the Bundestag)
BVerfGE 58, 170-171Order of 6 October 19812 BvC 4/81Electoral complaint (joinder by 100 eligible voters)
BVerfGE 58, 172-174Order of 6 October 19812 BvC 5/81Electoral complaint (joinder by 100 eligible voters)
BVerfGE 58, 175-176Order of 6 October 19812 BvC 7/81Electoral complaint (joinder by 100 eligible voters)
BVerfGE 58, 174-175Order of 6 October 19812 BvC 6/81Electoral complaint (joinder by 100 eligible voters)
BVerfGE 58, 176-177Order of 6 October 19812 BvC 8/81Electoral complaint (alleged electoral error influencing the allocation of seats in the Bundestag)
BVerfGE 58, 177-201Order of 6 October 19812 BvR 384/81Ineligibility of executive public employee of a district to serve on the council of a municipality belonging to the district (Lower Saxony)
BVerfGE 58, 202-208Order of 7 October 19812 BvC 2/81Right of a German civil servant of the European Communities to vote
BVerfGE 58, 208-233Order of 7 October 19812 BvR 1194/80Confinement of a mentally ill patient in a psychiatric hospital; right of the patient to a hearing prior to issuance of a non-appealable temporary order of confinement
BVerfGE 58, 233-256Order of 20 October 19811 BvR 404/78Ability to demand concessions from counterpart in labour disputes as a requirement for recognition as a union and party to collective bargaining
BVerfGE 58, 257-283Order of 20 October 19811 BvR 640/80On whether rules for the expulsion of students from school due to poor academic performance must be specified in statutory provisions
BVerfGE 58, 283-300Order of 20 October 19812 BvR 201/80Failure to meet the minimum rate in the statutory fee schedule for architects and engineers
BVerfGE 58, 300-353Order of 15 July 19811 BvL 77/78Administrative restrictions on property owner’s ground water rights (Federal Water Act; gravel mining; gravel quarrying at groundwater level)
BVerfGE 58, 353-357Order of 21 October 19811 BvR 1024/79Violation of the right to be heard (addressing key factual contentions in the reasons of the decision)
BVerfGE 58, 358-369Order of 21 October 19811 BvR 52/81Obligation to establish an employment relationship to make amends for damages caused as a condition of probation in the context of a suspended sentence
BVerfGE 58, 369-377Order of 22 October 19811 BvR 1369/79Interpretation of the rules relating to the recognition of occupational diseases in § 551 of the Reich Insurance Code
BVerfGE 58, 377-400Order of 3 November 19811 BvL 11/77,
1 BvL 85/78,
1 BvR 47/81
Early settlement of inheritance for children born outside of marriage

Volume 57

Table of contents volume 57
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 57, 1-9Order of 25 March 19812 BvE 1/79Inadmissibility of a complaint in Organstreit proceedings and of a constitutional complaint challenging the Federal Government’s answer to a Minor Interpellation on the anti-constitutional objectives of the political party Nationaldemokratische Partei Deutschlands (NPD)
BVerfGE 57, 9-28Order of 25 March 19812 BvR 1258/79Legal protection in connection with extradition request
BVerfGE 57, 29-39Order of 7 April 19812 BvR 446/80Prohibition on wearing uniforms at political events
BVerfGE 57, 39-43Order of 7 April 19812 BvR 911/80Reversal of Local Court decision due to violation of Art. 3(1) of the Basic Law because of a manifestly untenable assessment of a party’s submission
BVerfGE 57, 43-70Order of 7 April 19812 BvR 1210/80Prohibition of retired high level civil servants from serving on municipal councils
BVerfGE 57, 70-107Order of 8 April 19811 BvR 608/79Reconciling the requirement to provide the best possible treatment to patients in university hospitals with the guarantee of academic freedom for teaching physicians who provide the treatment (Hessian University Act)
BVerfGE 57, 107-117Order of 29 April 19811 BvL 11/78Differing treatment of those entitled to compensation under the earlier version of the Federal Epidemic Act
BVerfGE 57, 117-121Order of 29 April 19811 BvR 159/80Effectiveness of submission to court in complying with a deadline
BVerfGE 57, 121-139Order of 13 May 19811 BvR 610/77,
1 BvR 451/80
No authority for lawyers to be designated as ‘specialist in administrative law’
BVerfGE 57, 139-170Judgment of 26 May 19811 BvL 56/78,
1 BvL 57/78,
1 BvL 58/78
Provisions of the Severely Disabled Persons Act on the compulsory job quota and on the design and use of the compensation levy
BVerfGE 57, 170-182Order of 5 February 19812 BvR 646/80Monitoring of postal correspondence in remand detention between detainees and their parents
BVerfGE 57, 182-204Order of 5 February 19812 BvR 646/80Dissenting opinion of Justice Hirsch
BVerfGE 57, 204-220Order of 5 February 19812 BvR 646/80Dissenting opinion of Justice Wand
BVerfGE 57, 220-220Order of 5 February 19812 BvR 646/80Dissenting opinion of Justice Niebler
BVerfGE 57, 220-249Order of 17 February 192 BvR 384/78Access of external trade union representatives to charitable church organisations
BVerfGE 57, 250-295Order of 26 May 19812 BvR 215/81Criminal liability of working as an agent for an intelligence service; statements in judgment based on the written testimony of an ‘unavailable’ witness who was only questioned in writing; ‘hearsay witnesses’
BVerfGE 57, 295-335Judgment of 16 June 19811 BvL 89/78Requirements for private broadcasting (Saarland)
BVerfGE 57, 335-346Order of 16 June 19811 BvL 129/78Classification of lower contribution rates for female contributors to public pension insurance for the first five mandatory years of contribution
BVerfGE 57, 346-360Order of 16 June 19811 BvR 1094/80Requirement of a judicial authorisation for search of an apartment by enforcement officers of the tax office under Art. 13(2) of the Basic Law; scope of review and guarantee of the right to be heard in the context of a search warrant
BVerfGE 57, 361-394Judgment of 14 July 19811 BvL 28/77,
1 BvL 48/79,
1 BvL 154/79 inter alia
Maintenance claims of divorced or separated spouses under the First Act to Reform Marriage Law, hardship clauses for care and raising of shared child by spouse entitled to maintenance; supplementary claim of a gainfully employed divorced spouse; new maintenance rules also applicable to ‘old’ marriages

Volume 56

Table of contents volume 56
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 56, 1-22Order of 8 January 19812 BvL 3/77,
2 BvL 9/77
Pensions for residents of East Germany pursuant to the Federal Pensions Act (‘partial pension’)
BVerfGE 56, 22-37Order of 8 January 19812 BvR 873/80Criminal act within the meaning of Art. 103(3) of the Basic Law (committed in conjunction with membership in a criminal organisation)
BVerfGE 56, 37-54Order of 13 January 19811 BvR 116/77Debtor’s obligation to provide information in bankruptcy proceedings
BVerfGE 56, 54-87Order of 14 January 19811 BvR 612/72Exhaustion of recourse to ordinary courts prior to making claim in constitutional courts due to an administrative body’s failure to act (Düsseldorf-Lohausen airport); legislator’s obligation to improve law regarding the reduction of aircraft noise
BVerfGE 56, 87-99Order of 20 January 19812 BvR 993/77Remuneration of judges (classification of head of Bavarian Labour Courts)
BVerfGE 56, 99-110Order of 20 January 19812 BvR 632/78Inapplicability of a municipal prohibition of representation in a legal dispute (Municipal Code of North Rhine-Westphalia) to a lawyer associated in an office partnership with a municipal councillor
BVerfGE 56, 110-128Order of 20 January 19812 BvL 2/80On civil servants in the higher intermediate justice service performing public prosecution duties (as a subsidiary office) as regional representatives of the public prosecution office (Lower Saxony)
BVerfGE 56, 128-139Order of 28 January 19811 BvL 131/78Inadmissibility of a judicial referral; opinion of the referring Finance Court is manifestly untenable (forfeiture of right to year-end adjustment of wage taxes due to culpable failure to file within the deadline)
BVerfGE 56, 139-146Order of 28 January 19811 BvR 650/80Granting of separate fee waiver in regard to the execution of compulsory enforcement procedures
BVerfGE 56, 146-175Order of 4 February 19812 BvR 570/76,
2 BvR 571/76,
2 BvR 629/76 inter alia
Transition of high-level judicial officials to new remuneration scheme in Second Act on the Harmonisation and Revision of the Law Governing the Remuneration of Civil Servants
BVerfGE 56, 175-185Order of 4 February 19812 BvR 590/76Transition of lead public prosecutors (Baden-Württemberg) to the office of public prosecutors pursuant to new law on remuneration
BVerfGE 56, 185-187Order of 5 February 19812 BvR 1304/80Preliminary injunction; granting of fee waiver and appointment of lawyer for indigent defendant in private defamation litigation
BVerfGE 56, 187-192Order of 5 February 19812 BvR 1304/80Dissenting opinion of Justice Hirsch
BVerfGE 56, 192-216Order of 11 February 19811 BvR 303/78Prohibition on classifying university employee who was qualified as a professor and was primarily engaged in professorial tasks as a research assistant
BVerfGE 56, 216-244Order of 25 February 19811 BvR 413/80,
1 BvR 768/80,
1 BvR 820/80
Unconstitutionality of measures by immigration authorities to terminate right to residency on the basis of manifest abuses of law in the application for asylum prior to formal proceedings under the then-applicable statutory provisions
BVerfGE 56, 244-246Order of 28 February 19811 BvR 233/81Preliminary injunction; immediate execution of ban on demonstrations (Brokdorf)
BVerfGE 56, 247-249Order of 4 March 19812 BvR 195/81Seizure of photographs and negatives taken by media organisation’s own employees
BVerfGE 56, 249-266Order of 10 March 19811 BvR 92/71,
1 BvR 96/71
Expropriation legal only when conducted pursuant to an expropriation statute that is validly enacted within the constitutional division of powers for the respective competent legislator (Dürkheim gondola)
BVerfGE 56, 266-296Order of 10 March 19811 BvR 92/71,
1 BvR 96/71
Dissenting opinion of Justice Böhmer
BVerfGE 56, 296-297Order of 4 November 19801 BvR 92/71Continuation of constitutional complaint in the event of the sale of the property that is the subject of an expropriation order challenged under constitutional law
BVerfGE 56, 298-324Order of 7 October 19802 BvR 584/76,
2 BvR 598/76,
2 BvR 599/76 inter alia
Establishment of a noise protection zone by federal regulation for areas surrounding military air bases (Memmingen military air base)
BVerfGE 56, 324-347Order of 7 October 19802 BvR 584/76,
2 BvR 598/76,
2 BvR 599/76 inter alia
Dissenting opinion of Justices Wand and Niebler
BVerfGE 56, 347-353Order of 7 October 19802 BvR 584/76,
2 BvR 598/76,
2 BvR 599/76 inter alia
Dissenting opinion of Justice Hirsch
BVerfGE 56, 353-363Order of 11 March 19812 BvR 441/77Inclusion of supplemental allowance for judges in linear salary increases
BVerfGE 56, 363-395Judgment of 24 March 19811 BvR 1516/78,
1 BvR 964/80,
1 BvR 1337/80
No joint custody of child between mother and father who are unmarried even if the parents live together with their child and the mother consents; constitutionality of the statutory arrangement of unmarried father’s right of contact with his child
BVerfGE 56, 396-411Order of 24 March 19812 BvR 215/81Preliminary injunction; loss of right to hold public office and vote due to activity as a secret foreign agent

Volume 55

Table of contents volume 55
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 55, 1-7Order of 9 July 19802 BvR 701/80Preliminary injunction (Munich Airport planning approval order II; denial of expert testimony)
BVerfGE 55, 7-28Order of 15 July 19801 BvR 24/74,
1 BvR 439/79
Declaration of general applicability of collective bargaining agreements to joint institutions of the contracting parties
BVerfGE 55, 28-32Order of 15 August 19802 BvR 495/80Court-ordered supervision of offenders (after completion of a prison sentence of at least two years)
BVerfGE 55, 32-36Order of 7 October 19801 BvL 88/78,
1 BvL 126/78
Postponement of entry into effect of a declaration of leaving the church (Lower Saxony)
BVerfGE 55, 37-71Order of 7 October 19801 BvR 1289/78On the special influence exerted by university professors in collegial bodies due to the greater weight attached to their votes (Bremen)
BVerfGE 55, 72-95Order of 7 October 19801 BvL 50/79,
1 BvL 89/79,
1 BvR 240/79
Exclusion on appeal on points of fact and law of claims and defences that were properly excluded in civil proceedings at the first instance
BVerfGE 55, 95-100Order of 7 October 19802 BvR 1581/79Denial of right to be heard; opportunity to respond to new submission by opposing party in written proceedings
BVerfGE 55, 100-114Order of 8 October 19801 BvL 122/78,
1 BvL 61/79,
1 BvL 21/77
Legislative revision of a provision that was incompatible with the general guarantee of the right to equality under the Basic Law must apply retroactively (child bonus for social security benefits)
BVerfGE 55, 114-132Judgment of 21 October 19801 BvR 179/78,
1 BvR 464/78
No marital compensation for a woman for her previously drawn widow’s pension in the event of a third marriage; no revival of widow’s pension after dissolution of third marriage
BVerfGE 55, 132-134Order of 21 October 19801 BvR 614/79No reimbursement of costs for parties who were entitled to submit a statement in constitutional complaint proceedings, but who were not involved in the initial proceedings
BVerfGE 55, 134-144Order of 21 October 19801 BvR 1284/79Provision mandating divorce without exception after five-year separation is unconstitutional
BVerfGE 55, 144-154Order of 22 October 19802 BvR 1172/79,
2 BvR 1238/79
Obligation to provide information and access to documentation pursuant to the Act on Commercial Inland Waterway Transport
BVerfGE 55, 154-159Order of 22 October 19801 BvR 262/80Employment protection for pregnant employee who, through no fault of her own, did not inform employer of the existing pregnancy at the time of her dismissal
BVerfGE 55, 159-171Order of 5 November 19801 BvR 290/78No proof of firearms knowledge or completion of a shooting test required for applicants seeking a falconry license
BVerfGE 55, 171-184Order of 5 November 1980   1 BvR 349/80Consideration of the wishes of the child in a custody decision following the divorce of the parents and discretion of the court as to the question of in-person testimony of children under the age of 14
BVerfGE 55, 185-204Order of 18 November 19801 BvR 228/73,
1 BvR 311/73
Length of time in administrative duties needed in order for former civil servants and employees working at fiscal authorities to obtain exemption from tax consultant examination
BVerfGE 55, 205-206Order of 18 November 19801 BvR 194/78Decision not to admit appeal on points of law from Federal Court of Justice (Decision not to admit without reasons)
BVerfGE 55, 207-244Order of 25 November 19802 BvL 7/76,
2 BvL 8/76,
2 BvL 9/76
Authorisation to establish ordinances regulating secondary occupations of civil servants (North Rhine-Westphalia)
BVerfGE 55, 244-249Order of 2 December 19801 BvR 1222/77Subsidiarity of a constitutional complaint challenging a statute (Modernisation and Energy Savings Act)
BVerfGE 55, 249-261Order of 2 December 19801 BvR 436/78,
1 BvR 437/78
Payment requirements for permit to demolish obsolete housing despite intent to construct new or additional housing
BVerfGE 55, 261-273Order of 3 December 19801 BvR 409/80Conferral of the degree of ‘chartered engineer’ to graduates of universities of applied sciences
BVerfGE 55, 274-329Judgment of 10 December 19802 BvF 3/77Levy pursuant to Vocational Training Promotion Act
BVerfGE 55, 329-331Judgment of 10 December 19802 BvF 3/77Dissenting opinion of Justices Rinck, Steinberger and Träger
BVerfGE 55, 331-341Judgment of 10 December 19802 BvF 3/77Dissenting opinion of Justice Rottmann
BVerfGE 55, 341-345Judgment of 10 December 19802 BvF 3/77Dissenting opinion of Justice Hirsch
BVerfGE 55, 345-348Judgment of 10 December 19802 BvF 3/77Dissenting opinion of Justice Niebler
BVerfGE 55, 349-370Order of 16 December 1980 2 BvR 419/80Discretion of the Federal Government in granting protection from foreign states (Rudolf Hess)
BVerfGE 55, 370-372Order of 17 December 19801 BvL 50/80No competence for court officer to make referral to Federal Constitutional Court pursuant to Art. 100(1) of the Basic Law
BVerfGE 55, 372-397Order of 7 January 19812 BvR 401/76,
2 BvR 606/76
Salary adjustment for judges in Hesse to the federal level of remuneration for judges

Volume 54

Table of contents volume 54
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 54, 1-11Order of 25 March 19802 BvL 9/79,
2 BvL 10/79
Inadmissibility of referral for specific judicial review
BVerfGE 54, 11-39Order of 26 March 19801 BvR 121/76,
1 BvR 122/76
Differentiated taxation of civil servant pensions and retirement benefits from public pension scheme and supplementary pension funds
BVerfGE 54, 39-42Order of 27 March 19802 BvR 316/80Admissibility of the selection of ‘model proceedings’ and temporary suspension of 5,500 remaining appeal proceedings against planning approval order
BVerfGE 54, 43-46Order of 15 April 19801 BvR 1365/78Denial of right to be heard; failure to consider essential party submissions
BVerfGE 54, 47-53Order of 15 April 19802 BvL 7/77Inadmissibility of referral for specific judicial review
BVerfGE 54, 53-75Order of 15 April 19802 BvR 842/77Citizenship of person expatriated during Nazi regime
BVerfGE 54, 75-79Order of 15 April 19802 BvR 842/77Dissenting opinion of Justice Hirsch
BVerfGE 54, 80-86Order of 15 April 19802 BvR 461/79Denial of right to be heard; reinstatement proceedings
BVerfGE 54, 86-94Order of 15 April 19802 BvR 827/79Denial of right to be heard; failure to consider complaint and accompanying expert submissions
BVerfGE 54, 94-99Order of 15 April 19802 BvR 970/79Significance of constitutional guarantee of legal protection in military court proceedings (start of time period to bring further complaint)
BVerfGE 54, 100-117Order of 16 April 19801 BvR 505/78‘Entanglement in a system of injustice’ is not a mitigating factor that justifies lesser punishment than a life sentence for the murder of Jews during the Second World War
BVerfGE 54, 117-129Order of 29 April 19802 BvR 1441/79Application of preclusive provisions in civil proceedings
BVerfGE 54, 129-139Order of 13 May 19801 BvR 103/77Admissibility of evaluative statements in public discourse (public media commentary)
BVerfGE 54, 140-142Order of 13 May 19802 BvR 705/79Denial of right to be heard; no opportunity to provide final submission in main proceedings
BVerfGE 54, 143-148Order of 23 May 19802 BvR 854/79Prohibition on feeding pigeons
BVerfGE 54, 148-158Order of 3 June 19801 BvR 185/77Protection afforded individuals by general right of personality from having statements falsely attributed to them that impair their right to maintain a self-defined social image
BVerfGE 54, 159-172Order of 3 June 19801 BvL 114/78Authority of president of collegiate court to make referral for judicial review; member of a Chamber of Agriculture who also sat on an agricultural court in the first instance (Rhineland Palatinate)
BVerfGE 54, 173-207Order of 3 June 19801 BvR 967/78,
1 BvR 973/78,
1 BvR 627/78,
1 BvR 737/78
Teaching capacity as a metric for determining the maximum number of available university places in accordance with the agreement reached by the Standing Conference for the Ministers of Education and Cultural Affairs of the Länder
BVerfGE 54, 208-223Order of 3 June 19801 BvR 797/78General right of personality and freedom of expression; impermissible use of interpretation when criticising a person by quoting ambivalent statements they have made
BVerfGE 54, 223-224Order of 10 June 19802 BvC 1/80Electoral scrutiny complaint; European parliamentary election
BVerfGE 54, 224-236Judgment of 1 July 19801 BvR 23/75Communications made in physician-patient relationship regarding the results of an assessment conducted by Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians relating to the efficiency of the patient’s treatment
BVerfGE 54, 237-251Judgment of 1 July 19801 BvR 247/75Prohibition of partnerships between lawyers commissioned as notaries (Anwaltsnotare) and accountants
BVerfGE 54, 251-277Judgment of 1 July 19801 BvR 349/75,
1 BvR 378/76
Reimbursement of lawyer’s time and pro rata office costs incurred in handling large numbers of guardianships and conservatorships for persons with low income
BVerfGE 54, 277-300Order of 11 June 19801 PBvU 1/79Decision not to admit appeal on points of law pursuant to § 554 b of the Code of Civil Procedure
BVerfGE 54, 301-341Order of 18 June 19801 BvR 697/77Accounting privilege for persons in tax consulting professions
BVerfGE 54, 341-363Order of 2 July 19801 BvR 147/80,
1 BvR 181/80,
1 BvR 182/80
Requirements for the reasonableness of the return of previously persecuted asylum seeker to persecuting state
BVerfGE 54, 363-392Order of 8 July 19801 BvR 1472/78On the different electoral eligibility of professors for self-governing bodies at universities based on their salary grade (Baden-Württemberg)

Volume 53

Table of contents volume 53
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 53, 1-25Order of 4 December 19792 BvR 64/78,
2 BvR 460/79
Ordinances concerning the price of school books in public contracts void
BVerfGE 53, 25-30Order of 4 December 19792 BvR 376/77Denial of the right to be heard; reinstatement after expiration of time to appeal in labour court proceedings due to postal delays
BVerfGE 53, 30-96Order of 20 December 19791 BvR 385/77Peace-time use of atomic energy; violation of fundamental rights due to disregard of procedural provisions regarding licensing of atomic energy plants enacted in fulfilment of state’s duty of protection arising out of Art. 2(2) of the Basic Law
BVerfGE 53, 96-99Order of 3 January 19802 BvR 1022/79Advertising by pharmacy of non-pharmaceutical goods in a manner that violates professional advertising rules
BVerfGE 53, 100-109Order of 15 January 19802 BvL 1/79No change in the jurisdiction of local Social Courts in Hesse following reorganisation of regional boundaries as part of local government reform
BVerfGE 53, 109-114Order of 15 January 19802 BvR 920/79Denial of right to be heard; issuance of reinstatement order without opportunity for opposing party to respond
BVerfGE 53, 115-135Order of 16 January 19801 BvR 127/78,
1 BvR 679/78
Deadline for filing a restitution claim previously barred by law is invalid if the deadline had already expired by the time the law barring the claim was declared void
BVerfGE 53, 135-147Order of 16 January 19801 BvR 249/79Requirements for professional rules in the area of food law (absolute ban on products that could be confused with chocolate)
BVerfGE 53, 148-152Order of 5 February 19802 BvR 914/79Denial of the right to be heard; reinstatement due to postal delays
BVerfGE 53, 152-163Order of 6 February 19802 BvR 1070/79Limits on the length of time a suspended arrest warrant may be maintained
BVerfGE 53, 164-185Order of 26 February 19801 BvR 195/77Payment of old-age pension to German citizen who resided east of the Oder-Neiße border
BVerfGE 53, 185-205Order of 26 February 19801 BvR 684/78New rules relating to upper school levels in secondary schools in Hesse
BVerfGE 53, 205-206Order of 26 February 19801 BvR 1049/79Denial of right to be heard; unconstitutional decision to refrain from taking evidence
BVerfGE 53, 207-218Order of 26 February 19802 BvR 752/78Reimbursement of costs for lawyer who represents self in criminal or administrative penalty proceedings
BVerfGE 53, 219-224Order of 27 February 19801 BvR 277/78Denial of right to be heard; failure to consider a timely submission with a potential witness’s valid address for summons
BVerfGE 53, 224-256Judgment of 28 February 19801 BvL 136/78,
1 BvL 890/77,
1 BvL 1300/78 inter alia
New law providing for divorce based on irrefutable assumption of separation after three years of living apart; application to ‘old marriages’; hardship clauses
BVerfGE 53, 257-313Judgment of 28 February 19801 BvL 17/77,
1 BvL 7/78,
1 BvL 9/78 inter alia
Pension sharing between divorced spouses – including for ‘old marriages’ – as determination of the content and limits of property
BVerfGE 53, 313-332Order of 11 March 19801 BvL 20/76,
1 BvR 826/76
Obligation of recipients of miner’s association benefits and early pension and recipients of military pensions to pay contributions to the Federal Employment Agency when taking up a new job despite having no claim to unemployment benefits
BVerfGE 53, 332-336Order of 12 March 19801 BvL 9/72Establishment of amount in dispute in specific judicial review proceedings pursuant to the standard in § 113(2) third sentence of the Federal Fee Schedule for Lawyers
BVerfGE 53, 336-352Order of 12 March 19801 BvR 643/77,
1 BvR 644/77
Uncompensated withdrawal of a private carrier’s right to reimbursement of increased costs in facility maintenance due to the modification of a bridge pursuant to the 1939 Crossings Act
BVerfGE 53, 352-362Order of 12 March 19801 BvR 759/77Requirements for rent increases pursuant to the Second Act on Housing Protection (comparative rent)
BVerfGE 53, 362-366Order of 25 March 19801 BvR 159/78Decision not to admit constitutional complaint challenging statute that had been revised by the legislator in the interim
BVerfGE 53, 366-408Order of 25 March 19802 BvR 208/76State regulations on the structure and organisation of hospitals run by religious organisations or comparable or related institutions as a violation of the constitutional guarantee of churches’ right of self-determination (Hospital Act of North Rhine-Westphalia)
BVerfGE 53, 408-420Order of 25 March 19802 BvR 208/76Dissenting opinion of Justice Rottmann

Volume 52

Table of contents volume 52
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision Title
BVerfGE 52, 1-42Order of 12 June 19791 BvL 19/76Regulatory system of garden plot law (protection against termination, rental price fixing, prohibition of termed contracts)
BVerfGE 52, 42-58Order of 18 July 19792 BvR 488/76Exclusion of lawyer who served on municipal council from representing a third party in claim against the municipality
BVerfGE 52, 58-63Order of 18 July 19792 BvR 488/76Dissenting opinion of Justice Rottmann
BVerfGE 52, 63Order of 18 July 19792 BvR 488/76Dissenting opinion of Justice Hirsch
BVerfGE 52, 63-94Judgment of 24 July 19792 BvF 1/78Limits on tax deductions for contributions and donations to political parties
BVerfGE 52, 95-131Judgment of 24 July 19792 BvK 1/78Determination of the members of municipal association committees in the Land Schleswig-Holstein
BVerfGE 52, 131-171Order of 25 July 19792 BvR 878/74Constitutional requirements regarding the burden of proof in medical malpractice proceedings; physician’s duty to investigate
BVerfGE 52, 171-187Order of 25 July 19792 BvR 878/74Dissenting opinion of Justices Hirsch, Niebler and Steinberger
BVerfGE 52, 187-203Order of 25 July 19792 BvL 6/77In specific judicial review proceedings, the Federal Constitutional Court has no jurisdiction to decide that provisions of primary European Community law apply to the Federal Republic of Germany in a manner that contradicts the conclusion reached by the Court of Justice of the European Union in a preliminary ruling on the same initial proceedings
BVerfGE 52, 203-214Order of 3 October 19791 BvR 726/78Untimely receipt by court administration of submission that was timely received by the clerk of the office responsible for accepting submission
BVerfGE 52, 214-223Order of 3 October 19791 BvR 614/79Upholding the requirement to protect life and physical integrity and avoid disproportionate state interference when conducting an eviction from a rental apartment in compulsory enforcement proceedings
BVerfGE 52, 223-255Order of 16 October 19791 BvR 647/70,
1 BvR 7/74
Voluntary interdenominational school prayer in non-denominational municipal schools outside of religion class
BVerfGE 52, 256-264Order of 16 October 19791 BvR 124/71Constitutionality of a bar association’s decision to change the persons eligible to receive death benefit and changing from a surcharge to a lump sum contribution
BVerfGE 52, 264-277Order of 16 October 1979     1 BvL 5/77Differing rules as to premium payments for craft- and tradesmen than for other persons insured under the public pension scheme
BVerfGE 52, 277-283Order of 16 October 19791 BvL 51/79Youth from the age of 16 may attend public dances from 10:00 pm to midnight only when accompanied by parent or guardian
BVerfGE 52, 283-303Order of 6 November 19791 BvR 81/76Hearing of works council in context of the dismissal of media outlet employee whose job duties required adherence to editorial values
BVerfGE 52, 303-357Order of 7 November 19792 BvR 513/73,
2 BvR 558/74
Interference of the legislator in the assurance of the right of direct billing contained in the civil service appointment agreement of senior physicians through the implementation of hospital reform
BVerfGE 52, 357-369Order of 13 November 19791 BvL 24/77,
1 BvL 19/78,
1 BvL 38/79
Employment protection for pregnant employees who, through no fault of their own, did not inform employer of the existing pregnancy at the time of dismissal
BVerfGE 52, 369-379Order of 13 November 19791 BvR 631/78Right of single men with own household to paid day off for housework
BVerfGE 52, 380-391Order of 13 November 1979 1 BvR 1022/78Effect of Art. 12(1) of the Basic Law on the interpretation of procedural provisions for the First and Second State Examinations in Law
BVerfGE 52, 391-410Order of 14 November 19791 BvR 654/79Recognition as political refugee by another signatory to the Geneva Refugee Convention as evidence of actual feared political persecution in deportation proceedings before the competent German authority

Volume 51

Table of contents volume 51
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 51, 1-31Order of 20 March 19791 BvR 111/74,
1 BvR 283/78
Payment of pensions from German social security system to foreigners living abroad
BVerfGE 51, 31-37Order of 20 March 19791 BvR 111/74,
1 BvR 283/78
Dissenting opinion of Justice Katzenstein
BVerfGE 51, 37-43Order of 20 March 19791 BvR 111/74,
1 BvR 283/78
Dissenting opinion of Justices Faller and Niemeyer
BVerfGE 51, 43-60Order of 27 March 19792 BvL 2/77Exclusion of participation of staff council in the context of dismissals of certain groups of employees under the Bavarian Staff Representation Act
BVerfGE 51, 60-77Order of 27 March 19792 BvL 7/78Driving licence requirement when riding a powered bicycle that has been modified
BVerfGE 51, 77-96Order of 27 March 19792 BvR 1011/78Removal of civil servant member of staff council by majority of eligible voters (Staff Representation Act of the Land Bremen)
BVerfGE 51, 97-115Order of 3 April 1979 1 BvR 994/76Requirement of a special judicial order for the search of a debtor’s home in compulsory enforcement proceedings for the purpose of locating chattels under § 758 of the Code of Civil Procedure
BVerfGE 51, 115-125Order of 3 April 1979 1 BvL 30/76Assessment of unemployment benefits without consideration of payment for overtime hours worked
BVerfGE 51, 126-130Order of 3 April 1979 1 BvR 733/78Denial of right to be heard
BVerfGE 51, 130-145Order of 3 April 1979 1 BvR 1460/78,
1 BvR 1482/78,
1 BvR 27/79,
1 BvR 169/79
Admissibility of constitutional complaints that challenge administrative court decisions issued in preliminary proceedings prior to hearings on the main proceedings (review of educational capacity of universities)
BVerfGE 51, 146-150Order of 24 April 19791 BvR 449/77Reinstatement to status quo ante prior to missed deadline due to postal delays in private law proceedings
BVerfGE 51, 150-160Order of 24 April 19791 BvR 787/78Right to effective legal protection in the context of an enforced auction for the purpose of terminating a joint ownership
BVerfGE 51, 161-166Order of 25 April 19791 BvL 18/70Inadmissibility of referral for specific judicial review due to failure to address subsequently occurring events that appear to render question irrelevant
BVerfGE 51, 166-176Order of 25 April 19791 BvR 1012/76On the requirements for setting occupational rules by ordinance (Fuel Quality Description Ordinance)
BVerfGE 51, 176-188Order of 8 May 19792 BvR 782/78No judicial review of whether a ‘special public interest’ in prosecuting for bodily harm exists
BVerfGE 51, 188-193Order of 22 May 19791 BvR 1077/77Denial of right to be heard
BVerfGE 51, 193-222Order of 22 May 19791 BvL 9/75Entry of place name in vineyard registry; restrictions of use of place names on labels as a legal position guaranteed by Art. 14(1) first sentence of the Basic Law
BVerfGE 51, 222-257Order of 22 May 19792 BvR 193/79,
2 BvR 197/79
Five percent hurdle in European parliamentary elections
BVerfGE 51, 257-268Order of 13 June 19791 BvL 27/76Precedence of newly introduced health insurance for farmers over non-contributory health insurance for pensioners
BVerfGE 51, 268-295Order of 13 June 19791 BvR 699/77Temporary legal protection against school reorganisation actions (closure of a denominational school); closure of elementary school during transitional period without sufficient justification
BVerfGE 51, 295-304Order of 13 June 19791 BvL 97/78Secondary liability of opposing party for court costs assumed in a settlement agreement by indigent party
BVerfGE 51, 304-324Order of 19 June 19792 BvL 14/75Addition of periodical to the list of periodicals deemed dangerous to youth following final court decision
BVerfGE 51, 324-351Order of 19 June 19792 BvR 1060/78Constitutional limits to holding a criminal trial in light of an ailing defendant’s ability to participate in the proceedings
BVerfGE 51, 352-355Order of 9 June 19792 BvR 342/79Reinstatement to status quo ante prior to missed deadline due to postal delays in response to notice of execution
BVerfGE 51, 356-369Order of 26 June 19791 BvL 10/78Voluntarily continued insurance in German social security system for foreigners living abroad
BVerfGE 51, 369-384Order of 26 June 19791 BvR 290/79Transfer of professors who previously worked at pedagogical university of Saarland to University of Saarland following closure of institution
BVerfGE 51, 384-386Order of 18 July 19791 BvR 56/77Inadmissibility of an application to join a constitutional complaint with another proceeding in which a referral to the Plenary of the Federal Constitutional Court had already been made
BVerfGE 51, 386-401Order of 18 July 1979           1 BvR 650/77Deportation of a foreigner convicted of a criminal offence who is married to a German citizen and had has a child within the marriage
BVerfGE 51, 405-409Order of 18 July 19791 BvL 52/79Inadmissibility of referral for specific judicial review due to insufficient demonstration of the referred question’s relevance
BVerfGE 51, 401-405Order of 18 July 19791 BvR 655/79On whether a debtor may lodge a constitutional complaint in regard to an asset belonging to the bankruptcy estate

Volume 50

Table of contents volume 50
ReferenceDecisionFile referenceDecision title
BVerfGE 50, 1-4Order of 25 October 19781 BvR 761/78,
1 BvR 806/78
Reinstatement of appeal process in civil proceedings due to postal delays
BVerfGE 50, 5-15Order of 25 October 19781 BvR 983/78Life imprisonment for murderer with significantly reduced culpability
BVerfGE 50, 16-32Order of 8 November 19781 BvR 589/72Contestability of a caution issued against a lawyer in lieu of a formal complaint
BVerfGE 50, 32-37Order of 8 November 19781 BvR 158/78Time limit for lodging a constitutional complaint beginning with service of complete decision from civil court; denial of right to be heard (rejection of motion to hear evidence deemed ‘highly uneconomical’)
BVerfGE 50, 37-42Order of 10 November 19781 BvR 1180/78,
1 BvR 1185/78,
1 BvR 1205/78 inter alia
Preliminary injunction; temporary suspension of execution of judgment refusing the provisional allocation of a university place
BVerfGE 50, 42-48Order of 15 November 19782 BvL 13/77Tolling of statute of limitations when offender is immune from liability (§ 78b(2) Code of Criminal Procedure)
BVerfGE 50, 48-49Order of 15 November 1978 2 BvR 65/77Requirements for search warrant
BVerfGE 50, 50-56Order of 27 November 19782 BvR 165/75Municipal reorganisation in the area of Hanover; incorporation of parts of former town of Laatzen and former municipality of Rethen into Hanover
BVerfGE 50, 57-108Order of 19 December 19781 BvR 335/76,
1 BvR 427/76,
1 BvR 811/76 inter alia
Taxation of interest on deposits with credit institutions according to the nominal value
BVerfGE 50, 108-114Order of 19 December 19781 BvL 3/78Admissibility of referral for specific judicial review (rent increase in vacation and weekend homes; requirement to take evidence)
BVerfGE 50, 115-125Order of 16 January 19792 BvR 1148/76Decision of Federal Court of Justice not to admit appeal on points of law according to § 554b(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure
BVerfGE 50, 125-141Order of 16 January 19792 BvL 4/77Minimum prison sentence of six months for recidivism even for minor criminal offences (§ 48 Criminal Code)
BVerfGE 50, 142-166Order of 17 January 19791 BvL 25/77Failure to capture individual instances of criminal conduct within criminal law provision; violation of statutory maintenance obligation (§ 170b Criminal Code)
BVerfGE 50, 166-177Order of 17 January 19791 BvR 241/77Deportation of foreigner convicted of unauthorised possession of firearm on general preventative grounds
BVerfGE 50, 177-195Order of 17 January 19791 BvR 446/77,
1 BvR 1174/77
Differentiation of the crediting of substitute contribution periods and periods of unemployment and illness in the employee insurance scheme following self-employment within the scope of the Employee Insurance Act
BVerfGE 50, 195-205Order of 17 January 19792 BvL 6/76Naming of new municipality in context of municipal reorganisation
BVerfGE 50, 205-217Order of 17 January 19792 BvL 12/77Constitutionality of criminal punishment for theft of items of de minimus value
BVerfGE 50, 217-234Order of 6 February 19792 BvL 5/76Fee statute for North Rhine-Westphalia; fees for decisions on challenges to decisions on costs
BVerfGE 50, 234-244Order of 6 February 19792 BvR 154/78Exclusion of a newspaper reporter from participating in public court proceedings
BVerfGE 50, 244-253Order of 14 February 1979   1 BvR 924/78Cessation of recognised legal interest in bringing a constitutional complaint against a decision on the admissibility of extradition after Federal Government refusal to extradite
BVerfGE 50, 254-256Order of 28 February 1979   1 BvR 275/74Reimbursement of the costs incurred by adviser in filing a constitutional complaint
BVerfGE 50, 256-264Order of 28 February 19791 BvR 317/74Requirement that funeral urns remain in cemeteries
BVerfGE 50, 265-279Order of 28 February 19791 BvR 111/75Ability of pharmacy assistants to stand in for pharmacists
BVerfGE 50, 280-286Order of 28 February 1979   1 BvR 232/78Denial of right to be heard
BVerfGE 50, 287-290Order of 28 February 19792 BvR 84/79Decision of Federal Court of Justice not to admit appeal on points of law according to § 554b(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure
BVerfGE 50, 290-381Judgment of 1 March 19791 BvR 532/77,
1 BvR 533/77,
1 BvR 419/78,
1 BvL 21/78
1976 Codetermination Act
BVerfGE 50, 381-385Order of 13 March 19791 BvR 1085/77Written authorisation to submit constitutional complaint only issued after the deadline to submit constitutional complaint
BVerfGE 50, 386-397Order of 13 March 19792 BvR 72/76Non-deductibility of interest on private debt as special expenses
BVerfGE 50, 397-400Order of 13 March 19792 BvR 872/78Postal delays in submitting objection to notice of fine